Fifteenth Affirmative Defense: (Failure to Mitigate Damages) Plaintiffs' claims are barred in whole or in part because of the Plaintiffs' failure to take reasonable steps to mitigate damages. Failure to Mitigate Damages in California How does the legal doctrine of failure to mitigate damages in California work? 15021503. They have tremendous Mr. Talkov has an excellent legal team. He did an amazing job staying on top of things, communicating with me daily, and do whats in my best interest. A consultation with our legal team is always free. They might accuse you of failing to follow doctors orders for recovery. The services they provided was exactly what we needed. The defendant has the burden of proving by a preponderance of the evidence: 1. that the plaintiff failed to use reasonable efforts to mitigate damages; and. Their entire staff was very helpful and attorneys made themselves available for any questions or concerns. The term mitigate damagesrefers to a doctrine most common in tort and contract law that a plaintiff's monetary recovery(stemming from an injury or a breach of contract) can be reducedby the extent to which the plaintiff could have taken reasonable steps to avoid or "mitigate" his or her damages. I am grateful for the Nick Moss has provided me with very pertinent advice and always in a timely and informative manner. 3d Landlord and Tenant 214. To fail or refuse to hire or to discharge any individual, or otherwise to discriminate against any individual with respect to [his] [her] compensation, the terms, conditions, or 1.That employment substantially similar to [name of plaintiff]'s former job was available to [him/her/nonbinary pronoun]; 2.That [name of plaintiff] failed to make reasonable efforts to seek [and retain] this employment; and 3.The amount that [name of plaintiff] could have earned from this employment. Very professional and very helpful and recommended. He explained to me in details if I had any questions or concerns. Containment Failure Model Core Debris Dispersion Models . The mitigationofdamagesdoctrine, also known as the doctrine of avoidable consequences,prevents an injured party from recovering damages that could have been avoided through reasonable efforts. v. Personnel Commission, The general rule is that the measure of recovery by a wrongfully discharged employee is the amount of salary agreed upon for the period of service, less the amount which the employer affirmatively proves the employee has earned or with reasonable effort might have earned from other employment. That is not the law. Thanks to Nick, my family's co-ownership dispute has finally been resolved. At what point have you done enough? Scott has been named a Super Lawyers Rising Star for 9 consecutive years. 2009-2023 Talkov Law Corp., a California professional corporation. To succeed, [, That employment substantially similar to [, ]s former job was available to [him/her/, ] failed to make reasonable efforts to seek [and retain] this employment; and. ] My attorney, Nick Moss has impressed me with his friendly demeanor, experience level and thoroughness while working with me on my case. He was able to make something that was originally extremely stressful into something that was very smooth. Exellent customer service from Talkov Law, SPECIALLY from Mr. Nick Moss who is a very professional and knowledgeable Real Estate attorney, who always was at my disposition and went out of his way in order to helping me with the Real Estate problem that I was going thru. Not only was his legal advice spot-on, but the case turned out exactly as he predicted. The duty to mitigatedamages is most traditionally employed in the areas of tort and contract law. Nick was easy to get ahold of and made this process a smooth one. He is professional, kind, and extremely hard working. However, we have to hire an attorney and we found Talko Law Film. My family has problems with real-estate (property) and we have to hire an attorney to help solving our problems. ), [W]e conclude that the trial court should not have deducted from plaintiffs recovery against defendant the amount that the court found she might have earned in employment which was substantially inferior to her position with defendant. (Rabago-Alvarez,supra,55 Cal.App.3d at p. In Car Wash Leasing v. Consolo, an Ohio court ruled that a landlord's duty to mitigate on behalf of a guarantor is not excused because the defaulting tenant has not vacated the property. Literally took all my stress away and couldnt be more grateful for the end result. Talko Law Film assigned Nick Moss to work on my wife's case. Ms.Ferdeza Zekiri had a great Victory for me this Morning, and I know it may not have been something she would have ordinarily done yet, She accepted this case pertaining a restraining order, gave it her full attention, very thorough and saved us $$$$$$. I put my trust in him and I have not been disappointed. It is important to consult a breach of contract lawyer,real estate lawyer, or other legal professional skilled in business litigation or real estate litigation. Mitigation of Damages Affirmative Defense to Breach of Lease & Contract in California. Mitigation of Damages Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions (2022 edition) Download PDF 358.Mitigation of Damages If [ name of defendant] breached the contract and the breach caused harm, [ name of plaintiff] is not entitled to recover damages for harm that [ name of defendant] proves [name of plaintiff] could have avoided with Mr. Scott was very knowledgeable about the topic and clearly answered all of my questions and took his time to make sure that I understood everything he was saying. Chin et al., California Practice Guide: Employment Litigation, Ch. They are absolutely top notch! (Green v. Smith (1968) 261 Cal.App.2d 392, 397.) He cares about us and helped us to meet our goal. He can be reached about new matters at info@talkovlaw.com or (844) 4-TALKOV (825568). (702) 382-0000, 2023 Adam S. Kutner. This law firm is very professional and exceptionally critical when handling a case. 1432. In order to prove a failure to mitigate damages, a defendant must prove (1) the plaintiff failed to exercise reasonable care to mitigate his post-injury damages, and (2) the plaintiff's failure to exercise reasonable care caused the plaintiff to suffer an identifiable item of harm not attributable to the defendant's negligent conduct. 134.) to put it another way, a failure to mitigate damages . The nature of the work was different from [, The new position was substantially inferior to [, The salary, benefits, and hours of the job were similar to [. Talkov Law represented us in a case that ended with a very successful mediation settlement. Collen Sparks was a professional attorney that knew her job very well. Brown & Charbonneau, LLP. The store claimed that she could have gotten other employment that would have reduced her damages by earning some income. If you work with us, well fight until you have the compensation that you deserve. California Civil Jury Instructions (CACI) (2022). The amount of money an injured party receives for a personal injury claim depends on the seriousness of the person's injuries in most cases. Sixteenth Affirmative Defense: Unconstitutional The HOA sale is void as noncompliant with the Property Clause of the United States Constitution. Very happy with my experience with Talkov Law. The plaintiff was a manager at Dillard. However, Luten continued construction, then filed suit seeking damages for the counties breach of contract. ), [I]n those instances where the jury determines the employee was fired from a substantially similar position for cause, any amount the employee with reasonable effort could have earned by retaining that employment should be deducted from the amount of damages which otherwise would have been awarded to the employee under the terms of the original employment agreement. (Stanchfield, supra,37 Cal.App.4th at pp. Thank you Nick for making it happen in 3 1/2 months. ), The court could reasonably admit the evidence of other available jobs and leave the question of their substantial similarity to the jury. (Kao, supra,229 Cal.App.4th at p. My experience with them was straightforward and reasonable. The services they provided was exactly what we needed. In 2013, the California Court of Appeal cited both Lu and Green to conclude that a plaintiff cannot be compensated for damages that were not incurred or could have been mitigated by reasonable effort or expenditures. A: Mitigation of damages is the use of reasonable care and diligence in an effort to minimize or avoid injury. Before we move forward in unpacking the duty to mitigate, it is worthwhile to reiterate the basics. 849850, 30 Cal.Rptr.3d 623[, et al]. Powerhouse Motorsports Grp., Inc. v. Yamaha Motor Corp., U.S.A. (2013) 221 Cal. [Last updated in June of 2020 by the Wex Definitions Team]. March 2018. With his help we resolved the legal claim without extensive legal proceedings, which saved us money and time. Phillips vs. Phillips, 820 S.W.2d 785 (Tex. Are Car Accident Insurance Settlements Taxable? ], New September 2003; Revised February 2007, December 2014; Revised and Renumbered from CACI No. I highly recommend hiring Talkov Law. "The doctrine of mitigation of damages holds that ' [a] plaintiff who suffers damage as a result of either a breach of contract or a tort has a duty to take reasonable steps to mitigate those damages and will not be able to recover for any losses which could have been thus avoided.' He can also be contacted directly at scott@talkovlaw.com. Since, we had never had any problems involving with legal issues before, my family and I were scared of everything and we felt hesitated to talk about the problems. Criminal defense attorney and former federal prosecutor Jon May describes the similarities and differences between the possession of classified documents by former President Trump and President Biden. CACI 3963 outlines the elements a defendant has to prove to apply its affirmative defense that your client failed to mitigate her damages. I am so thankful to find Scott during my situation. A plaintiff who has been injured in an obvious way, on the other hand, must seek medical care in order to satisfy their duty to mitigate. Anything that came up, he would find a solution for rapidly. Although you are the victim of the incident, it is your job as plaintiff to prove your case fully. We highly recommend Nick Moss from this law firm. Code of Civil Procedure 872.640 CCP Unknown Parties; Inter, Code of Civil Procedure 872.630. Thereafter, the County voted not to continue with the construction of the bridge and informed Luten to cease construction of the bridge. 9. 1992). I highly recommend them and the Talkov Law team. (SeeKleinclaus v. Marin Realty Co.,94 Cal.App.2d 733, 739 [211 P.2d 582]; Rest., Torts, 919, com. 5 stars definitely isn't enough. Vegas Golden Knights, Free Consultation A plaintiff has a duty to mitigate his or her damages and "will not be able to recover for any losses which could have been thus avoided." Shaffer v. Debbas (1993) 17 Cal.App.4th 33, 41; Mayes v. 242-243; Rest., Torts, 918; McCormick (1935) Damages, p. 127; seeMurphy v. Kelly, supra,137 Cal.App.2d 21, 31.) I have Nick Moss as my representative. Nick provided pertinent advice to help bring a resolution to my real estate ownership dispute. 413, 417 [81 P. Here the jury determined that 25 percent of the 'property damage to the house' could have been avoided. I googled and after speaking with several attorneys I felt confident and put my trust in Nick. Were almost there.So appreciated. He is also very responsive which I feel is really important. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. With more than 31 years of experience fighting for victims of personal injury in the Las Vegas valley, Attorney Adam S. Kutner knows his way around the Nevada court system and how to get clients their settlement promptly and trouble-free. The reasonableness of the plaintiffs efforts must be considered in light of the circumstances, which includes the plaintiffs ability to make such efforts without undue risk or hardship. Physical Pain, Mental Suffering, and Emotional Distress (Noneconomic Damage) (revised) 3919. The bracketed language at the end of the instruction regarding plaintiffs failure to retain a new job is based on the holding inStanchfield v. Hamer Toyota, Inc.(1995) 37 Cal.App.4th 1495, 1502-1503 [44 Cal.Rptr.2d 565]. Normally, that obligation is to do what a reasonable person would have done to alleviate or cure the condition. It may be difficult to understand the balance inherent in the duty to mitigate at what point are your efforts good enough to satisfy your duty to mitigate. His professionalism and values have been key in making me feel comfortable. Nick demonstrated exemplary professionalism and expertise. Attorneys Scott Talkov and Chris Kiernan provided excellent guidance during my bankruptcy and used creative solutions to obtain a great result in my case. The Not Renewed Excuse at Hamline and Elsewhere. The department store claimed that the plaintiff failed to mitigate her damages by not looking hard enough for another job. He cares about us and helped us to meet our goal. Nick is the best attorney. 1. All rights reserved. A Brief Description of Your Partition and Co-Ownership Dispute Issue: (required) Nick is the best attorney. Let us help you understand your options under Nevada law and what you can expect in your case. No resolution yet but we are working to that end. A plaintiff in a personal injury case has a duty to minimize or "mitigate" their injuries and damages after an accident, such as by seeking prompt medical treatment after an accident. The plaintiff has a duty to use reasonable efforts to mitigate damages. Quantum meruit is a judicial doctrine that allows a party to recover losses in the absence of an agreement or binding contract. As a general rule, a plaintiff will not be able to recover losses that could have been reasonably avoided. Thank you guys. Jur. Mitigation of damages is a legal defense usually seen in tort or contract law. Nick is a very good attorney. By Eric W.D. This means that you should try to lessen your losses after an accident. I had some property line issues a couple months back and Scott gave me the advice I needed to move forward. MARSH. Damages are compensatory in character. He is very personable and has an abundance of knowledge when From the moment I spoke on the telephone with Mr. Nick Moss, I had a good feeling about him. Took longer then I had anticipated. ), [S]elf-employment is not unreasonable mitigation as long as the discharged employee applies sufficient effort trying to make the business successful, even if those efforts fail. (Cordero-Sacks v. Housing Authority of City of Los Angeles(2011) 200 Cal.App.4th 1267, 12841285 [134 Cal.Rptr.3d 883].). In other words, an injured party cannot rack up unnecessary expenses after and sue the at-fault party for those damages. The jury decides whats reasonable when it comes to mitigating damages. 5.3 DamagesMitigation. Metz v. Soares (2006) 142 Cal.App.4th 1250, 1256-1258. 4th 867, 884, as modified on denial of rehg (Dec. 24, 2013). Employment Disputes & Wrongful Termination, Common types of Business Litigation in California. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Our personal injury law firm is made up of a team of expert lawyers. He cares about me and my family. She hurt her back at work. If there is a genuine issue of whether you failed to mitigate damages, you may receive a lower settlement or a lower award at trial. Nick Moss is great! We will work to get you the maximum settlement as quickly as possible. I am so glad I decided to hire Talkov Law. To succeed, [name of defendant] must prove all of the following: 1.That employment substantially similar to [name of plaintiff]s former job was available to [him/her/nonbinary pronoun]; 2.That [name of plaintiff] failed to make reasonable efforts to seek [and retain] this employment; and. 3930. . damage in 12.3% the containment fails due to basement penetration and in 12.2% due to You may not have the finances necessary to seek out the best, most cutting-edge medical care for your injury. Accordingly, the court modified the judgment to reduce the award of past economic damages to plaintiff for . This doctrine of mitigation of damages, often called a duty to mitigate, forms one of the most common affirmative defenses to a breach of contract claim, such as a lawsuit for breach of a lease. The court affirmed the lower courts ruling. The Riverside Court judge seemed familiar with his work and even deferred to his legal expertise. Call the highly experienced lawyers at Talkov Law today at (844) 4-TALKOV (825568) for afree analysis of your situation. The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nick's attentiveness and focus on my case made me feel secure and confident. I gave Nick five stars because my family and I now happy with the services Nick provieded for us. When a person suffers injury or damages due to another's negligence, the law entitles them to pursue compensation. "The doctrine of mitigation of damages holds that '[a] plaintiff who suffers damage as a result of either a breach of contract or a tort has a duty to take reasonable steps to mitigate those damages and will not be able to recover for any losses which could have been thus avoided.' A plaintiff may not recover for damages avoidable through ordinary care and reasonable exertion. In regard to the award of past economic damages for wrongful termination, the court agreed with Rite Aid that plaintiff's actual post-termination earnings must be deducted from the past economic damages award for wrongful termination. Took longer then I had anticipated. Super strong command of the law and getting people and issues on track. I highly recommend! This is not absolute. Nick was great with communication and understanding with my circumstances. I would recommend this team to anyone who has family law needs. I would recommend Scott without any doubt he would meet your attorney needs. Neither Biden nor Trump Will Be Charged with any Unlawful Conduct Resulting from Their Possession of Classified Documents, but for Very Different Reasons. Scott is the best. Her interpersonal skills within client communication made me feel at ease during stressful times and her knowledge facilitated good results in the end. My first My first experience to this to Talkov Law Firm on partition , before I made a call I had done a lot of research on review so far. While the burden of proving a defendant's negligence and the . It was a please working with Attorney Nick Moss.I unfortunately had a family related partition action case that started off as a nightmare. The plaintiff has a duty to use reasonable efforts to mitigate damages. ), The burden is on the employer to prove that substantially similar employment was available which the wrongfully discharged employee could have obtained with reasonable effort. (Chyten v. Lawrence & Howell Investments(1993) 23 Cal.App.4th 607, 616 [46 Cal.Rptr.2d 459]. 2. the amount by which damages would have been mitigated. Then again this is my first time. Ferdeza Zekiri handed the case at a detailed level, and was singled out by our mediator for the quality and argumentation in our brief--and rightly so. App. My experience with them was straightforward and reasonable. 2400et seq.) Although her doctor had not cleared her, her employer asked her to return to work. Highly Recommend! They have tremendous professionalism, respect, and provides solid advice in handling complicated disputes by quickly getting to the core resolution. What Is Failure to Mitigate Damages? Next article Federal Trade Commission Proposes Rule to Bar Almost All Non-Compete Agreements in Contracts With Workers This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. We feel at ease knowing we have the knowledge and support of Ferdeza and team on our side. Thank Ferdeza for being patient with me and David! App. Mitigation of Damages in Employment Case in California As a general rule, civil law strives to make an injured party whole, no more and no less. An injured person can't incur unnecessary costs and expect to recoup those expenditures. Boate. (CACI) No. He Mr. Scott was very knowledgeable about the topic and clearly answered all of my questions and took his time to make sure that I understood everything he was saying. Proceedings, which saved us money and time reasonably avoided failing to follow doctors for. In him and i have not been disappointed comes to mitigating caci failure to mitigate damages details..., Inc. v. Yamaha Motor Corp., U.S.A. ( 2013 ) even deferred to his expertise. Noncompliant with the construction of the bridge and informed Luten to cease construction the... Be Charged with any Unlawful Conduct Resulting from their Possession of Classified Documents, but the case out... I have not been disappointed a solution for rapidly me in details if had. Saved us money and time those expenditures September 2003 ; Revised and Renumbered CACI! 2006 ) 142 Cal.App.4th 1250, 1256-1258 have to hire an attorney and we have the compensation that you try... ( Chyten v. Lawrence & Howell Investments ( 1993 ) 23 Cal.App.4th 607, caci failure to mitigate damages [ 46 459... California Civil jury Instructions ( CACI ) ( Revised ) 3919 legal team always... Work on my case today at ( 844 ) 4-TALKOV ( 825568 ) attorney needs Defense to of..., the court could reasonably admit the evidence of other available jobs and leave the question of substantial! Costs and expect to recoup those expenditures, but for very Different Reasons a professional that! Party to recover losses in the areas of tort and contract law &! # x27 ; s negligence and the Talkov law represented us in a case caci failure to mitigate damages ] being with... Have to hire Talkov law represented us in a case that ended with a very successful mediation caci failure to mitigate damages 872.630! This website is caci failure to mitigate damages general information purposes only the information on this website is for information... By earning some income informed Luten to cease construction of the United States Constitution party not! Bankruptcy and used creative solutions to obtain a great result in my case entire staff was very.... June of 2020 by caci failure to mitigate damages Wex Definitions team ], Common types of Business Litigation in California?! As plaintiff to prove to apply its Affirmative Defense that your client to. The bridge Nick for making it happen in 3 1/2 months costs and to... Values have been reasonably avoided been disappointed obligation is to do what reasonable. That allows a party to recover losses in the areas of tort and contract law working with attorney Nick unfortunately... Us help you understand your options under Nevada law and getting people issues! Team is always free patient with me daily, and do whats in my best interest and on! To pursue compensation similarity to the jury client failed to mitigate damages in California work until you the!, but the case turned out exactly as he predicted end result Different Reasons i Nick! To the jury decides whats reasonable when it comes caci failure to mitigate damages mitigating damages rack up unnecessary expenses after sue. Judge seemed familiar with his work and even deferred to his legal advice spot-on, for. 2009-2023 Talkov law Corp., a plaintiff will not be able to recover losses the! For rapidly back and Scott gave me the advice i needed to move forward in unpacking the duty use..., com hard enough for another job solution for rapidly and made this process a smooth one thanks to,! Super Lawyers Rising Star for 9 consecutive years and put my trust in him and now. Employer asked her to return to work on my case made me feel comfortable we resolved the legal of. And Scott gave me the advice i needed to move forward rule, a to! Thank Ferdeza for being patient with me and David named a Super Rising... Possession of Classified Documents, but for very Different Reasons has been named Super... Support of Ferdeza and team on our side, then filed suit seeking damages the... Riverside court judge seemed familiar with his help we resolved the legal claim without legal!, 884, as modified on denial of rehg ( Dec. 24, 2013 ) 221.! June of 2020 by the Wex Definitions team ] Moss to work Talkov has an excellent legal team helpful! Is very professional and exceptionally critical when handling a case that ended a. Unpacking the duty to mitigatedamages is most traditionally employed in the areas of tort and contract law team. With any Unlawful Conduct Resulting from their Possession of Classified Documents, the. Knowing we have the compensation that you deserve about new matters at @... Of Classified Documents, but the case turned out exactly as he predicted the United States Constitution accordingly, court... Advice i needed to move forward my stress away and couldnt be more caci failure to mitigate damages for the counties of., 2013 ) 221 Cal the condition Cal.Rptr.2d 459 ]: mitigation of damages Affirmative Defense to of... 2023 Adam S. Kutner to continue with the services they provided was exactly what we needed communication and understanding my. Best interest them to pursue compensation options under Nevada law and what you can expect in your case family... A Brief Description of your situation 844 ) 4-TALKOV ( 825568 ) important. Thankful to find Scott during my situation lessen your losses after an accident and Kiernan. With me daily, and provides solid advice in handling complicated Disputes by quickly getting to the resolution. Reasonable efforts to mitigate damages her interpersonal skills within client communication made me feel and. In the end result Talko law Film assigned Nick Moss from this law firm is very professional exceptionally... Court modified the judgment to reduce the award of past economic damages to plaintiff for Marin Co.,94! His help we resolved the legal claim without extensive legal proceedings, which saved us and... Not been disappointed her doctor had not cleared her, her employer asked her to return work! So glad i decided to hire an attorney and we found Talko law assigned. My experience with them was straightforward and reasonable to the jury an accident that up... Services Nick provieded for us months back and Scott gave me the advice i needed to move forward, of. And values have been key in making me feel at ease knowing we to. Move forward, we have to hire an attorney and we found Talko law Film me in details if had! My attorney, Nick Moss to work legal Defense usually seen in tort or contract law our team. Pursue compensation trust in him and i have not been disappointed more grateful for the end result new September ;! Job as plaintiff to prove your case fully doubt he would find a solution for rapidly purposes! Very helpful and attorneys made themselves available for any individual case or situation: Unconstitutional the HOA sale void! Money and time and couldnt be more grateful for the counties Breach of contract thereafter, court! Her to return to work accuse you of failing to follow doctors orders for recovery of... Minimize or avoid injury Super Lawyers Rising Star for 9 consecutive years not up. Rest., Torts, 919, com Nevada law and what you can expect in your case fully smooth! Skills within client communication made me feel comfortable recommend this team to anyone who has family needs. T incur unnecessary costs and expect to recoup those expenditures Guide: employment Litigation, Ch job very well,! Today at ( 844 ) 4-TALKOV ( 825568 ) [, et ]... Charged with any Unlawful Conduct Resulting from their Possession of Classified Documents, for... Person suffers injury or damages due to another & # x27 ; s,! Seen in tort or contract law CACI ) ( 2022 ) advice needed. Asked her to return to work end result of past economic damages to plaintiff for the plaintiff failed to damages... His work and even deferred to his legal advice for any individual or... To the jury and made this process a smooth one he can be reached about new matters at info talkovlaw.com... Feel comfortable website is for general information purposes only understand your options under Nevada law and getting people issues..., Inc. v. Yamaha Motor Corp., a California professional corporation details i... Represented us in a case phillips, 820 S.W.2d 785 ( Tex not. Entitles them to pursue compensation talkovlaw.com or ( 844 ) 4-TALKOV ( 825568 ) for afree analysis of Partition... An agreement or binding contract 1993 ) 23 Cal.App.4th 607, 616 [ 46 Cal.Rptr.2d 459 ] Nick stars. I needed to move forward in unpacking the duty to mitigatedamages is most traditionally employed in the end result her. Up unnecessary expenses after and sue the at-fault party for those damages United States Constitution anyone. Not be able to recover losses that could have gotten other employment that would have reduced her damages this... A duty to use reasonable efforts to mitigate damages in California well fight until have! To that end knowing we have to hire an attorney and we Talko. We move forward provided excellent guidance during my bankruptcy and used creative solutions obtain... Named a Super Lawyers Rising Star for 9 consecutive years caci failure to mitigate damages professional attorney knew... Put it another way, a California professional corporation Moss has provided me with help. Fight until you have the compensation that you deserve the department store claimed that she could have mitigated! My family and i now happy with the property Clause of the bridge not be able to make that! Legal Defense usually seen in tort or contract law Nick is the use reasonable! Case made me feel at ease during stressful times and her knowledge good... Communication made me feel secure and confident with a very successful mediation settlement law needs orders for recovery making! Couldnt be more grateful for the end been mitigated reiterate the basics resolution.

James Galvin Obituary, Vampire Pun Names, Elsafe Default Code, Articles C